Close Menu
Energy NewsEnergy News
  • NEWS
    • Breaking News
    • Hydrogen
    • Energy Storage
    • Grid
    • SMR
    • Projects
    • Production
    • Transport
    • Research
  • SPOTLIGHT
    • Interviews
    • Face 2 Face
    • Podcast
    • Webinars
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
    • Reviews
    • Events
  • REGIONAL
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia
    • Europe
    • Middle east
    • Pacific
  • COMMUNITY
  • ABOUT
    • Advisory Board
    • Contact us
    • Report Your News
    • Advertize
    • Subscribe
LinkedIn X (Twitter) YouTube Facebook
Trending
  • Australia’s Green Fertiliser Revolution: Inside the GEGHA Hydrogen & Ammonia Project
  • PGE Adds 475 MW of Battery Storage, Boosting Grid Reliability in Oregon
  • Horizon Fuel Cell Group Acquires Hyzon Motors’ Vehicle IP to Revive Hydrogen Truck Business
  • Statkraft Advances 400MW Shetland Hydrogen-to-Ammonia Project at Former Scatsta Airport
  • Multi-Objective Optimization Transforms Lithium-Ion Battery Management
  • Chile’s $3.6 Billion Hydrogen Bet
  • Import Cost Pressures Drive German Hydrogen Strategy Toward Domestic Production Despite Scale Constraints
  • Towngas and CIMC ENRIC Forge Alliance on Green Methanol and Hydrogen in Hong Kong
LinkedIn X (Twitter) YouTube Facebook
Energy NewsEnergy News
  • NEWS
    • Breaking News
    • Hydrogen
    • Energy Storage
    • Grid
    • SMR
    • Projects
    • Production
    • Transport
    • Research
  • SPOTLIGHT
    • Interviews
    • Face 2 Face
    • Podcast
    • Webinars
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
    • Reviews
    • Events
  • REGIONAL
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia
    • Europe
    • Middle east
    • Pacific
  • COMMUNITY
  • ABOUT
    • Advisory Board
    • Contact us
    • Report Your News
    • Advertize
    • Subscribe
Energy NewsEnergy News
Home Home - Interviews
hydrogen

Beyond the Buzzwords: Josh Carmichael on Hydrogen’s Hard Realities and Future Opportunities

Arnes BiogradlijaBy Arnes Biogradlija19/12/20243 Mins Read
Share
LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email WhatsApp Telegram

Hydrogen might be the energy transition’s most promising yet polarizing player. With global investments soaring into the hundreds of billions, it remains a battleground of competing technologies, entrenched political interests, and engineering roadblocks.

WATCH THE FULL INTERVIEW HERE

Josh Carmichael—a leader who has helped shape energy projects from Australia’s mega-battery to global hydrogen ventures—believes that the industry’s fragmented strategies risk stalling its potential.

While the hydrogen debate often focuses on colors or feasibility, Carmichael reframes it: What will it take for hydrogen and batteries to collaborate rather than compete?

Core Tension and Challenges in Adoption

The hydrogen industry suffers from fragmented priorities and misplaced ambitions. Carmichael criticizes the industry’s obsession with differentiating technologies by color codes—green, blue, gray—and argues that this overcomplication distracts from solving foundational issues like scalability and financing. He highlights an overlooked but critical problem: despite vast capital availability, projects consistently fail to reach Final Investment Decisions (FIDs) due to mismatched priorities between stakeholders.

Carmichael points to the battery sector for lessons learned. Early adopters prioritized clear market segments, from frequency control to short-term storage, building credibility one step at a time. In contrast, hydrogen projects frequently overpromise and underdeliver, attempting to tackle everything from transportation fuel to fertilizer feedstocks without securing reliable offtake agreements.

Modular vs. Mega Projects

The scale of hydrogen projects has also come under scrutiny. Carmichael sees value in modular, smaller-scale solutions that can be deployed rapidly and iterated instead of the sprawling mega-projects that dominate headlines but rarely achieve milestones. He shares insights from his experience, illustrating how these smaller projects are faster and often more cost-effective, reducing risks tied to regulatory delays and over-engineering.

Policy Pitfalls and Market Missteps

Policy frameworks around hydrogen have also drawn Carmichael’s critique. He points to the European Union’s additionality and time-matching requirements for electrolyzers as prime examples of counterproductive regulation. These measures, he argues, hinder innovation by imposing rigid operational constraints that don’t reflect market realities. In contrast, he praises South Australia’s pragmatic approach, where bipartisan collaboration allowed for scalable projects that married private-sector efficiency with public-sector backing.

What’s Missing: Trust and Collaboration

For all its technical complexity, Carmichael believes the hydrogen industry’s real missing link is trust. Too often, stakeholders—whether governments, developers, or financiers—approach projects from entrenched silos, failing to align objectives or share risks equitably. He recounts successful case studies, like South Australia’s battery project, where trust and transparency between public and private sectors drove rapid execution and long-term value.

hydrogen
Share. LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email

Related Posts

Hydrogen

Australia’s Green Fertiliser Revolution: Inside the GEGHA Hydrogen & Ammonia Project

08/08/2025
PGE Adds 475 MW of Battery Storage, Boosting Grid Reliability in Oregon

PGE Adds 475 MW of Battery Storage, Boosting Grid Reliability in Oregon

08/08/2025
Horizon Fuel Cell Group Acquires Hyzon Motors’ Vehicle IP to Revive Hydrogen Truck Business

Horizon Fuel Cell Group Acquires Hyzon Motors’ Vehicle IP to Revive Hydrogen Truck Business

08/08/2025
hydrogen

Statkraft Advances 400MW Shetland Hydrogen-to-Ammonia Project at Former Scatsta Airport

08/08/2025
Batteries Battery

Multi-Objective Optimization Transforms Lithium-Ion Battery Management

08/08/2025
hydrogen

Chile’s $3.6 Billion Hydrogen Bet

08/08/2025
Hydrogen

Australia’s Green Fertiliser Revolution: Inside the GEGHA Hydrogen & Ammonia Project

08/08/2025
PGE Adds 475 MW of Battery Storage, Boosting Grid Reliability in Oregon

PGE Adds 475 MW of Battery Storage, Boosting Grid Reliability in Oregon

08/08/2025
Horizon Fuel Cell Group Acquires Hyzon Motors’ Vehicle IP to Revive Hydrogen Truck Business

Horizon Fuel Cell Group Acquires Hyzon Motors’ Vehicle IP to Revive Hydrogen Truck Business

08/08/2025
hydrogen

Statkraft Advances 400MW Shetland Hydrogen-to-Ammonia Project at Former Scatsta Airport

08/08/2025

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from the hydrogen market subscribe to our newsletter.

LinkedIn X (Twitter) Facebook YouTube

News

  • Inteviews
  • Webinars
  • Hydrogen
  • Spotlight
  • Regional

Company

  • Advertising
  • Media Kits
  • Contact Info
  • GDPR Policy

Subscriptions

  • Subscribe
  • Newsletters
  • Sponsored News

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from EnergyNewsBiz about hydrogen.

© 2025 EnergyNews.biz
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms
  • Accessibility

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.