Close Menu
Energy NewsEnergy News
  • NEWS
    • Breaking News
    • Hydrogen
    • Energy Storage
    • Grid
    • SMR
    • Projects
    • Production
    • Transport
    • Research
  • SPOTLIGHT
    • Interviews
    • Face 2 Face
    • Podcast
    • Webinars
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
    • Reviews
    • Events
  • REGIONAL
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia
    • Europe
    • Middle east
    • Pacific
  • COMMUNITY
  • ABOUT
    • Advisory Board
    • Contact us
    • Report Your News
    • Advertize
    • Subscribe
LinkedIn X (Twitter) YouTube Facebook
Trending
  • Doug Wicks on Why Energy Innovation Is Broken—and How to Fix It
  • Why Latin America is Crucial for the Global Green Hydrogen Revolution
  • Senators’ “Big, Beautiful” Betrayal: How Clean Energy Lost Its Lifeline
  • Sodium-Ion Batteries Gain Ground as Lithium Costs and Supply Risks Reshape Storage Markets
  • Why Energy Storage Is the New Backbone of Frequency Regulation in Renewable Power Systems
  • Eve Energy’s $1.2B Malaysia Battery Bet Reveals Strategic Shift Amid Global Trade Volatility
  • Oman: Heavy Equipment Arrives for $750M ACME Project
  • Saxony-Anhalt Deploys €87M in Targeted Green Hydrogen Subsidies
LinkedIn X (Twitter) YouTube Facebook
Energy NewsEnergy News
  • NEWS
    • Breaking News
    • Hydrogen
    • Energy Storage
    • Grid
    • SMR
    • Projects
    • Production
    • Transport
    • Research
  • SPOTLIGHT
    • Interviews
    • Face 2 Face
    • Podcast
    • Webinars
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
    • Reviews
    • Events
  • REGIONAL
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia
    • Europe
    • Middle east
    • Pacific
  • COMMUNITY
  • ABOUT
    • Advisory Board
    • Contact us
    • Report Your News
    • Advertize
    • Subscribe
Energy NewsEnergy News
Home Home - Interviews
Douglas Wicks

Doug Wicks on Why Energy Innovation Is Broken—and How to Fix It

Arnes BiogradlijaBy Arnes Biogradlija01/07/20255 Mins Read
Share
LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email WhatsApp Telegram

In 2023, U.S. venture investment in energy innovation dropped 27% from its 2021 peak. While inflation and interest rates played a role, insiders suggest a more systemic issue: a stagnating ecosystem that fails to scale bold ideas. Doug Wicks, a former Program Director at ARPA-E, has seen firsthand why so many promising solutions fall short—not in the lab, but in the systems meant to support them.

WATCH THE FULL INTERVIEW HERE

Wicks, now an independent strategic advisor, believes the U.S. energy innovation pipeline is undermined by bureaucratic inertia and a reluctance to prioritize “fast failure” over procedural rigor. “We’re not going anywhere,” he clarifies, “we’re just not going fast enough.” His critique comes at a time when the stakes are escalating. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), global energy-related CO₂ emissions rose to 37.4 gigatonnes in 2023, a record high, with clean tech deployment still lagging what’s needed for net zero by 2050.

At ARPA-E, the Advanced Research Projects Agency–Energy, Wicks spent six years funding high-risk, high-reward energy projects. The agency is modeled on DARPA’s fast-moving, high-impact approach. But as Wicks explains, energy innovation hasn’t benefited from the same urgency. “It can take years to approve a new program,” he says, citing internal resistance, leadership delays, and the lack of an agile funding mechanism. “In the meantime, transformative ideas lose steam or get scooped by faster ecosystems.”

The Leadership Bottleneck

One of the structural flaws Wicks highlights is the Senate-confirmed leadership requirement for ARPA-E. During Biden’s first term, ARPA-E was without a confirmed director for two out of four years. Wicks compares this with DARPA, which operates under a direct presidential appointment, allowing immediate strategic pivots. The result, he says, is predictable: “Without someone at the helm, no one wants to make a risky call. So nothing gets done.”

This vacuum doesn’t just delay decisions—it stifles program design. Wicks argues that too often, funding programs prescribe the solution rather than define the problem. “If you want to catalyze transformation, you don’t tell innovators how to solve it—you define what success looks like and let them figure it out.”

From Radical to Real

Some of the most promising ideas Wicks backed came from what he calls “white space”—unexplored areas like geologic hydrogen or radically reimagined mining. Startups like Phoenix Tailings emerged with unconventional approaches to industrial waste and mineral recovery. In one case, the founding team began their lab work on a back porch. “They didn’t wait for approval. They put skin in the game,” he recalls.

These ventures thrived because of their readiness to pivot, a trait Wicks believes should be a core criterion in funding. “The 10–15% of projects that go from lab to commercial scale all had one thing in common: adaptable leadership, not just good science.”

Yet, as Wicks notes, ARPA-E’s system has little tolerance for failure. When a project doesn’t meet early objectives, teams are often forced to re-enter a bureaucratic grant cycle, even if the core team is strong. “Industry would never fire its researchers after one failed product,” he says. “Why do we do it in public research?”

A Broken Economic Lens

Wicks also challenges techno-economic assumptions that fuel current policy directions. He aims for green hydrogen as a case study. “People kept saying we’d get to $1/kg hydrogen through electrolysis. But the thermodynamic input alone—40 kWh per kilogram—made that cost fantasy unless electricity was practically free.”

He calls the collapse of many green hydrogen startups in 2024 a foreseeable outcome. “We ignored basic economic inputs. It was like making sawdust from mahogany and calling it innovation.”

Instead, Wicks sees promise in natural hydrogen, geologically sourced hydrogen that may offer better economics and scalability. ARPA-E was among the first U.S. agencies to treat the field seriously. But even then, Wicks says, building momentum required 40–50 public talks and over 200 phone calls. “That’s how far outside the Overton window we were.”

Rewiring the System

Asked what it would take to fix this, Wicks points to a three-part framework: prioritize impact over pure science, evaluate without assuming subsidies, and radically reduce the time from idea to funding. He’s not against basic research, but insists the system must differentiate between speculative science and near-commercial potential.

The ideal, he argues, is a system that “runs fast, fails fast, and recycles the talent,” rather than punishing teams for failing to hit early-stage metrics. One of his best-performing projects, Rock Zero, was a complete pivot from the original objective. Under current systems, such a shift might have triggered termination.

In his final months at ARPA-E, Wicks was increasingly vocal about the need to treat subsurface mining, geologic hydrogen, and geothermal as a strategic infrastructure layer. “Everything we use, from wind turbines to batteries, comes out of the ground,” he says. “But we still mine like the Romans. That’s not innovation. That’s inertia.”

Final Takeaway

As the global energy transition collides with geopolitical instability and material shortages, the ability to move fast is no longer optional. It’s existential. The question, Wicks suggests, is not whether we have the tools—it’s whether we’re willing to let go of the systems that keep them locked away.

climate energy storage hydrogen minerals
Share. LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email

Related Posts

Hydrogen

Why Latin America is Crucial for the Global Green Hydrogen Revolution

01/07/2025
Energy Policy Hydrogen Clean

Senators’ “Big, Beautiful” Betrayal: How Clean Energy Lost Its Lifeline

30/06/2025
Sodium-Ion

Sodium-Ion Batteries Gain Ground as Lithium Costs and Supply Risks Reshape Storage Markets

30/06/2025
Energy Storage

Why Energy Storage Is the New Backbone of Frequency Regulation in Renewable Power Systems

30/06/2025
Batteries

Eve Energy’s $1.2B Malaysia Battery Bet Reveals Strategic Shift Amid Global Trade Volatility

30/06/2025
Oman

Oman: Heavy Equipment Arrives for $750M ACME Project

30/06/2025
Douglas Wicks

Doug Wicks on Why Energy Innovation Is Broken—and How to Fix It

01/07/2025
Hydrogen

Why Latin America is Crucial for the Global Green Hydrogen Revolution

01/07/2025
Energy Policy Hydrogen Clean

Senators’ “Big, Beautiful” Betrayal: How Clean Energy Lost Its Lifeline

30/06/2025
Sodium-Ion

Sodium-Ion Batteries Gain Ground as Lithium Costs and Supply Risks Reshape Storage Markets

30/06/2025

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from the hydrogen market subscribe to our newsletter.

LinkedIn X (Twitter) Facebook YouTube

News

  • Inteviews
  • Webinars
  • Hydrogen
  • Spotlight
  • Regional

Company

  • Advertising
  • Media Kits
  • Contact Info
  • GDPR Policy

Subscriptions

  • Subscribe
  • Newsletters
  • Sponsored News

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from EnergyNewsBiz about hydrogen.

© 2025 EnergyNews.biz
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms
  • Accessibility

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.