Close Menu
Energy NewsEnergy News
  • NEWS
    • Breaking News
    • Hydrogen
    • Energy Storage
    • Grid
    • SMR
    • Projects
    • Production
    • Transport
    • Research
  • SPOTLIGHT
    • Interviews
    • Face 2 Face
    • Podcast
    • Webinars
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
    • Reviews
    • Events
  • REGIONAL
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia
    • Europe
    • Middle east
    • Pacific
  • COMMUNITY
  • ABOUT
    • Advisory Board
    • Contact us
    • Report Your News
    • Advertize
    • Subscribe
LinkedIn X (Twitter) YouTube Facebook
Trending
  • 2025 Global Electricity Market: Growth, Emissions Challenges, and Renewable Energy Dynamics
  • TWO DAY MASTERCLASS ON: EXPLOITATION & COMMERCIALIZATION POTENTIAL OF NATURAL HYDROGEN
  • Tesla’s $4.3B South Korean Battery Deal Exposes Critical Supply Chain Vulnerabilities as Tariff Pressures Mount
  • Austria’s €3.5B Hydrogen Gambit: Infrastructure Investment Against European Market Skepticism
  • Brazil’s Hydrogen Pipeline Swells to 111 Projects—But Deep Challenges Stall Progress
  • Nuclear-Hydrogen Integration Faces Reality Check as AI Demand Reshapes Energy Infrastructure
  • Germany’s Hydrogen Acceleration Act: Regulatory Relief Amid Market Reality Gap
  • Why Canada’s Zero-Emission Transit Revolution Is Stuck in Neutral
LinkedIn X (Twitter) YouTube Facebook
Energy NewsEnergy News
  • NEWS
    • Breaking News
    • Hydrogen
    • Energy Storage
    • Grid
    • SMR
    • Projects
    • Production
    • Transport
    • Research
  • SPOTLIGHT
    • Interviews
    • Face 2 Face
    • Podcast
    • Webinars
    • Analysis
    • Columnists
    • Reviews
    • Events
  • REGIONAL
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia
    • Europe
    • Middle east
    • Pacific
  • COMMUNITY
  • ABOUT
    • Advisory Board
    • Contact us
    • Report Your News
    • Advertize
    • Subscribe
Energy NewsEnergy News
Home Home - Analysis
Green Hydrogen H2 News

Germans pull the breaks on hydrogen trains

Arnes BiogradlijaBy Arnes Biogradlija03/11/20223 Mins Read
Share
LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email WhatsApp Telegram

Germans pull the breaks on hydrogen trains following the first actual tests, the findings demonstrating how much more expensive this alternative is when compared to standard electric or battery solutions.

The state of Baden-Württemberg was one of the first to wager on hydrogen trains. On 16 distinct lines, a small fleet of hydrogen fuel cell-powered trains has been operating to learn more about the capabilities and restrictions of the technology. As a result, hydrogen completely failed.

Hydrogen fuel cell trains “will no longer be considered in the foreseeable future for a variety of operational and financial reasons,” according to officials in charge of the effort.

State transport minister Winfried Hermann outlined the benefits and drawbacks of the three electric solutions under consideration in a report: traditional electric trains, battery hybrid trains, and hydrogen trains.

Results of hydrogen trains tests

The advantages of hydrogen trains include reduced effect during operation and transition because no modifications to the rail infrastructure are required. The drawbacks, however, were undeniable and some of them stood out, including the high cost of the infrastructure for refueling, low efficiency, high energy consumption, the high cost of hydrogen itself, the limited supply of green hydrogen, and the requirement to constantly top off the service stations’ deposits.

The state has provided estimated figures for the cost of the infrastructure over a 30-year period using several techniques. The result is that a hydrogen system would have an overall cost of ownership of 849 million euros. A sum comparable to the 588 million euros for traditional electric trains or the 506 million euros for an electric type driven by batteries.

Accordingly, a battery-powered or traditional electric model will cost between 31 and 67% less than the hydrogen vehicle in this series. However, these variations greatly depend on the line. For instance, on the Nagoldtalbahn, the cost would be 81% less for the battery-electric variant (262 million euros) if hydrogen were used.

Given this situation, experts have advised state officials to replace diesel locomotives with battery-powered electric trains in three of the six subnetworks and to use conventional electric trains in the other three, though they have also added that in each case the cost difference between battery-electric and overhead power lines would be “small” or “very small”.

Germans pull the breaks on hydrogen trains
Germans pull the breaks on hydrogen trains
Germans pull the breaks on hydrogen trains

Another issue has been added to the list of causes, in addition to the high cost of infrastructure and hydrogen, and that is the uncertainty around how much green hydrogen will be accessible in the upcoming years for hydrogen trains.

See the full report here.

MIREO PLUS H

Siemens has created two-car, regional hydrogen trains with a next-generation hydrogen motor system for the project’s one-year trial run. The locomotive is propelled by two separate systems, each of which consists of a fuel cell and a lithium-ion battery. Depending on operational conditions like the season or route, the Mireo Plus H has a range of up to 800 kilometers and is as powerful as an electric multiple-unit train. The range for a three-car version is up to 1,000 kilometers. The train has low lifespan costs as a result of its lower maintenance and repair expenses. 160 kilometers per hour is the highest speed of the Mireo Plus H.

Share. LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email

Related Posts

Electricity

2025 Global Electricity Market: Growth, Emissions Challenges, and Renewable Energy Dynamics

31/07/2025
NATURAL HYDROGEN

TWO DAY MASTERCLASS ON: EXPLOITATION & COMMERCIALIZATION POTENTIAL OF NATURAL HYDROGEN

31/07/2025
Battery

Tesla’s $4.3B South Korean Battery Deal Exposes Critical Supply Chain Vulnerabilities as Tariff Pressures Mount

30/07/2025
hydrogen

Austria’s €3.5B Hydrogen Gambit: Infrastructure Investment Against European Market Skepticism

30/07/2025
Hydrogen

Brazil’s Hydrogen Pipeline Swells to 111 Projects—But Deep Challenges Stall Progress

30/07/2025
Nuclear

Nuclear-Hydrogen Integration Faces Reality Check as AI Demand Reshapes Energy Infrastructure

30/07/2025
Electricity

2025 Global Electricity Market: Growth, Emissions Challenges, and Renewable Energy Dynamics

31/07/2025
NATURAL HYDROGEN

TWO DAY MASTERCLASS ON: EXPLOITATION & COMMERCIALIZATION POTENTIAL OF NATURAL HYDROGEN

31/07/2025
Battery

Tesla’s $4.3B South Korean Battery Deal Exposes Critical Supply Chain Vulnerabilities as Tariff Pressures Mount

30/07/2025
hydrogen

Austria’s €3.5B Hydrogen Gambit: Infrastructure Investment Against European Market Skepticism

30/07/2025

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from the hydrogen market subscribe to our newsletter.

LinkedIn X (Twitter) Facebook YouTube

News

  • Inteviews
  • Webinars
  • Hydrogen
  • Spotlight
  • Regional

Company

  • Advertising
  • Media Kits
  • Contact Info
  • GDPR Policy

Subscriptions

  • Subscribe
  • Newsletters
  • Sponsored News

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from EnergyNewsBiz about hydrogen.

© 2025 EnergyNews.biz
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms
  • Accessibility

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.